Reclaimed vs New Bricks: What Should You Choose?
When repairing older brickwork, the choice between reclaimed bricks and new manufactured bricks is not simply about colour. The two options can differ in dimensions, surface texture, weathering, hardness, edge profile and availability. The right comparison depends on the building and the reason for the repair.
Why reclaimed bricks can look different
Reclaimed bricks have already experienced weather, mortar, handling and possibly cleaning. Their faces may be softened, chipped or stained. A batch from one demolition project can also contain bricks from more than one production period or manufacturer.
Advantages and limitations of new bricks
New bricks normally have more consistent dimensions and a documented product specification. They can be easier to source in quantity. However, a new brick may look cleaner or brighter than a weathered wall, and a nominally similar colour does not guarantee a convincing visual match.
Check the dimensions
Measure the existing brick and compare it with the proposed product. Reclaimed bricks can have worn edges that reduce apparent dimensions, while new bricks are normally manufactured to a specified tolerance. Check several existing units before deciding that one measurement represents the whole wall.
Check texture and edge character
Look at the face under natural light. Is it sandfaced, smooth, wirecut, handmade-looking, textured or speckled? Compare the arrises and end faces as well. These details can make two bricks with similar base colours look completely different once they are laid next to each other.
Check the sample in the actual location
A sample should be viewed against the existing wall rather than only under a showroom light. Look at it from several distances. Mortar colour and joint profile also affect the overall appearance, so consider the repair as a complete piece of brickwork rather than a collection of isolated colour swatches.
Reclaimed brick quality checks
- Check for excessive frost damage or deep spalling.
- Look for remnants of mortar that obscure the face.
- Check dimensions across multiple bricks.
- Ask about the source and age where known.
- Confirm whether the bricks have been aggressively cleaned.
Identify your existing brick or read the replacement matching guide.